Listing Tools

Nestled in the heart of Nantucket's Historic District, this home offers an excellent location and total privacy - an ideal island retreat. Spacious and stately, 14 Gardner Street balances the best of both worlds - tastefully preserved historic charm with modern comforts and convenience. Perfect for family gatherings and elegant entertaining, the sprawling layout offers an array of rooms - formal and informal - to accommodate every scenario. French doors in the living room and family dining room open onto a stone patio. Surrounded by privet hedges and a beautiful garden, this backyard is an oasis. Beyond the privet lies a spacious guest cottage at 7 Howard Court. Totally private, with a separate driveway and entrance, this charming cottage is perfect for guests or tenants. First Floor This stately home, circa 1843, welcomes you with a double staircase, elegant foyer and original historic details that are exquisitely preserved. Informal entrances, on either side of the home, offer easy access from the driveway, side and rear of the home. The thoughtful layout makes daily living easy, and also creates an impressive statement. Two parlors (one used as an office) and a dining room are on the front side of the home (which retains its historic footprint). Large family/living area, kitchen, informal dining and screened porch extend from there. You can find privacy and quiet in these rooms, or entertain large groups of people. They are multi-functional. Second Floor Two separate staircases lead to the second floor. At the front of the house, the original antique staircase, with a custom-painted mural of island imagery, leads to two bedrooms and a gallery space. The main staircase, in the family/living room, leads to an upstairs center hall with access to all four bedrooms, as well as stairs leading to the third-floor bunk room. Each one of the five bedrooms has an ensuite bathroom. The primary bedroom also has a cozy sitting room and French doors opening onto a private balcony overlooking the garden. A perfect place for stretching in the morning or relaxing in the afternoon sun. Two of the secondary bedrooms boast original fireplaces, and all have been tastefully updated. Third Floor A fun and historic space that evokes the whaling days of the 1800s, the third floor has exposed original chestnut beams and paneling adorned by19th century hand-carved names of whaling ships. Four built-in beds, with individual book shelves and nautical lights, make this the perfect sleeping area for children or teens. The attic bedroom also has a full bathroom with double vanity and large shower. Basement Arriving back from the beach, you can rinse off in the outdoor shower and immediately enter the house through the lower level to drop off your towels and beach gear in the basement laundry room. Two sets of washers/dryers, a large utility sink and a powder room make it easy to leave the sand behind before you go upstairs and enter the main living space. Secondary Dwelling Perfectly appointed for guests and extended family, the guest cottage features a separate shelled driveway, parking for two cars, and two stories of living space. It is light-filled and cozy, with two bedrooms and one full bathroom upstairs and a kitchen, living, dining area as well as a half-bath and laundry room downstairs. A rear deck, screened by privet hedge, allows for outdoor cooking, dining and enjoying warm summer breezes in total privacy.

More Info


  • GarageNo
  • Garage Spaces


  • Year Built1843
  • Year Built DescriptionActual
  • Bathroom10
  • Bathrooms10
  • Full Bathrooms6
  • Half Bathrooms4
  • Bedrooms7
  • Total Rooms15
  • Stories2
  • FoundationBlock
  • Square Feet5087
  • BasementYes
  • Basement DescriptionFinished
  • Lead PaintUnknown
  • Separate Living QtrsYes


  • Heat SystemForced Hot Air
  • Hot Water Water HeatTankless
  • CoolingCentral Air
  • Water Sewer UtilityPublic Sewer
  • Fuel TypePropane Gas


  • Total Assessments$3,826,200
  • Improvement Assessment$2,372,600
  • Land Assessments$1,453,600

Basic Information

  • Virtual TourView Tour
  • Property TypeA
  • Property Subtype 1Single Family Residence
  • List Price$5,395,000
  • Sale Price$5,395,000
  • Sale Date12/03/2021
  • MLS Number22106687
  • MLS StatusClosed


  • Acreage0.19
  • TownNantucket
  • Lot Size SourceAssessor
  • Lot Size Square Feet8402
  • Flood ZoneNot Verified
  • Street DescriptionPaved, Public
  • RenovatedYes


  • PoolNo
  • Other AmenitiesBasement, Garden


  • Modification Date2021-12-03T08:35:59
  • Original Price$5,395,000
  • Year RoundYes
  • Publish to Internet1
  • IrregularYes
  • DOM21
  • Special List CondNone
  • Date Listed11/08/2021
  • View Count1


  • Building Number14
  • Unit Number
  • StreetGardner Street and 7 Howard Ct
  • Street Suffix
  • VillageNantucket
  • StateMA
  • Zip02554
  • CountyNantucket
  • Street Direction
  • Directions to PropertyFrom Main St, turn left on Gardner St.
  • School DistrictNantucket


  • Exterior Features
    • Deck
    • Fenced Yard
    • Outdoor Shower
    • Patio
    • Porch
    • Underground Sprinkler
    • Yard
  • Roof DescriptionShingle
  • Property StyleAntique
  • Siding DescriptionShingle

Water Body

  • WaterfrontNo
  • Water ViewNo
  • Beach DescriptionNone
  • Water AccessNone
  • DockNo


  • Number of Photos68
  • Last Picture Change Date2021-11-08T10:20:28

Map Location

Driving Directions

Listing Courtesy of Fisher Real Estate

Sold by Member Non of cci.unknownoffice

broker reciprocity The data relating to real estate for sale on this site comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Summary or thumbnail real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Lomenzo Properties, Inc. are marked with the BR Logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker. Neither the listing broker nor Lomenzo Properties, Inc. shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints and shall be held totally harmless.

This site was last updated December 4, 2021. All properties are subject to prior sale, changes, or withdrawal.

Lomenzo Properties, Inc. has chosen to display only certain towns and/or types or styles of properties. This site may not show all listings that are available through the Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc.

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:


Do not fill in this field: